The Best Omelette Pans: Our Top 5 Recommendations

Like making omelettes? By switching from a regular frying pan to a smaller omelette pan, you’ll get more control over how you cook your eggs, letting you get the perfect creamy center that’s always tough with a full size frying pan.

Omelette pans are designed to make the process of cooking an omelette easier. They’re smaller than regular frying pans, and in some cases, even have a folding lid to let you cook frittatas and other dishes.

To help you avoid wasting money on an omelette pan that doesn’t work as well as it should, we tested a variety of the most popular omelette pans on the market. We compared all of the pans we reviewed on factors like value for money, quality, ease of use and versatility.

Below, you’ll find our five top recommendations for the best omelette pans available today. For our full reviews, scroll down the page to our “Best Omelette Pans” section. You can also use the quick links below to jump directly to our favorite omelette pans on Amazon.com:

  • If you’re looking for a cheap and simple omelette pan that’s perfectly sized for making great omelettes, we recommend the T-fal E93802 Professional Nonstick Pan, which has a convenient temperature indicator..
  • If you’re looking for a classic, cast iron omelette pan that provides better heat retention and distribution, we recommend the Lodge Pro-Logic P10S3 Pre-Seasoned Skillet.
  • If you’re looking for a pan that can prepare omelettes and frittatas, we recommend the Nordic Ware Italian Frittata and Omelette Pan, which has a mess-free hinge system that lets you flip omelettes and frittatas without spreading the contents onto your stove.

What to Look For in an Omelette Pan

Have you ever tried to prepare an omelette in a large frying pan? If so, you’ll know how difficult it is to create a thick, fluffy omelette. Instead of sticking together and creating a thick omelette, the large size of the pan means the beaten eggs are far more likely to spread out and thin.

This makes size the number one factor you should look for in an omelette pan — namely, a small size. As a general rule, we recommend looking for an omelette pan that’s eight to nine inches.

An eight to nine inch pan is large enough to produce a thick, soft and perfectly cooked omelette from three or four eggs. Most of the omelette pans we’ve recommended fit into this size bracket.

If you like a larger omelette and use five or six eggs, you can upgrade to a 10 inch pan. It’s best to avoid larger pans unless you like a thin, pancake-like omelette without a soft center. While it’s somewhat obvious, it’s also best to avoid griddle pans with grill patterns.

Since you’ll need to turn your omelette as it cooks, you should also look for a pan with a gradual rise around its diameter. A shallow lip and soft edge makes it easier to reach into the pan with a spatula and flip your omelette.

If you’re health conscious, it’s definitely worth buying an omelette pan with a non-stick surface to reduce the amount of oil you need to use. Finally, any good omelette pan should have a strong and reliable handle that won’t come loose or break easily.

We’ve selected our recommendations below based on these characteristics, meaning any pan you see below has passed our standards for quality, results and value for money.

The Best Omelette Pans

T-fal E93802 Professional Total Nonstick Thermo-Spot Fry Pan

best non-stick omelette pan

The T-fal E93802 is a non-stick frying pan that’s perfect for cooking omelettes. It has a non-stick surface, meaning there’s no need to use excess butter or cooking oil, as well as a Thermo-Spot heat indicator that tells you when the pan has reached the right heat for cooking.

This frying pan comes in a variety of sizes, ranging from eight to 12.5 inches. We recommend the eight inch pan for preparing omelettes, as the two larger pans disperse the eggs over too large a surface.

One of the biggest advantages of the E93802 is its Thermo-Spot indicator. Located right in the center of the pan, the heat indicator light up when the pan reaches the perfect heat for cooking, helping you avoid burning your eggs or pouring them into a cold pan.

This pan has a stainless steel base that’s compatible with induction stoves. It’s fitted with a full Prometal non-stick surface that keeps your eggs (and other foods) from sticking, even at very high heat. It’s even dishwasher safe and safe to use in the oven at temperatures up to 400°F.

Finally, it has a recessed silicone handle. Because the handle is set back from the pan itself, it doesn’t heat up with the pan, making it completely safe to pick the pan up from the stove.

Priced under $20, the T-fal E93802 is an excellent pan sold at a very good price. Just make sure you order the eight inch version, as the two larger pans, while good for general cooking, are just too big for preparing omelettes.

Click here to check the current price for the T-fal E93802 Professional Total Nonstick Thermo-Spot Fry Pan on Amazon.

Cuisinart 722-18NS Chef’s Classic Stainless Nonstick 7-Inch Open Skillet

best omelette pan 2017

Measuring seven inches across, the Cuisinart 722-18NS is an excellent pan for preparing small omelettes and scrambled eggs. Because of its small size, this pan is best for  omelettes that use three eggs or less. It’s also available in eight, 10 and 12 inch sizes for preparing larger dishes.

Thanks to its aluminum encapsulated base, the 722-18NS takes very little time to heat up. It has no “hot spots,” as you would find on cheaper pans, with heat evenly distributed around the entire pan. This makes it easy to prepare omelettes without burning the center due to excessive heat.

It also has a titanium reinforced non-stick interior that reduces the amount of oil you need to use to prepare an omelette. The rim of the pan is tapered and lowers into the base smoothly, making it easy to flip omelettes, pancakes and other flat dishes.

This pan doesn’t have a heat indicator spot, meaning you’ll need to guess the temperature. This isn’t much of a difficulty, and after using the pan a few times you’ll quickly work out the right heat level for cooking eggs properly.

Since this pan is made of stainless steel, it’s completely safe to use in the dishwasher. All in all, the Cuisinart 722-18NS is a great pan that, for less than $15 at retail, offers impressive quality and value for money.

Click here to check the current price for the Cuisinart 722-18NS Chef’s Classic Stainless Nonstick 7-Inch Open Skillet on Amazon.

Cuisinart FP2-24BK Frittata 10-Inch Nonstick Pan Set

omelette and frittata pan reviews

Designed specifically for cooking frittatas, the Cuisinart FP2-24BK Frittata 10-Inch Nonstick Pan Set is also great for preparing omelettes. This pan set includes two frying pans that can lock into each other, making it easy to flip your frittata or omelette from one pan to the other.

The second pan also doubles as a lid, letting you retain moisture and prepare a variety of dishes using this pan set.

For preparing omelettes, the FP2-24BK works very well. At 10 inches, the pans are larger than most omelette pans, making this pan set a good option if you like to make your omelettes with four, five or six eggs. Since there are two pans, you can cook two omelettes simultaneously.

This pan set really excels when you need to prepare frittatas. Since the pans lock right into each other at the handle, flipping the frittata is as simple as connecting the pans and then flipping one upside down to let the contents fall into the other.

Beyond the uniqueness of an interlocking two-pan set, the pans included in the FP2-24BK set are very good. They have a high quality non-stick surface that works well at high heat, as well as aluminum core construction for quick heating and perfect heat distribution.

They’re dishwasher safe and designed to tolerate temperatures of up to 350°F, making them safe to use in the oven. For less than $30 a set, the Cuisinart FP2-24BK is a great addition to your kitchen, even if you only end up using one of the two pans most of the time.

Click here to check the current price for the Cuisinart FP2-24BK Frittata 10-Inch Nonstick Pan Set on Amazon.

Nordic Ware Italian Frittata and Omelette Pan

best high quality omelette pan

Another frittata pan, the Nordic Ware Italian Frittata and Omelette Pan is split at the center into two separate pans. With a sealed, mess-free hinge design, this pan lets you quickly and easily flip omelettes and frittatas without any risk of spreading the contents onto your stove.

Like all of the omelette pans we’ve reviewed, the Nordic Ware Italian Frittata and Omelette Pan has a non-stick coating, making it easy to cook omelettes and other egg-based dishes at a high temperature without using excessive amounts of butter or oil.

It also has durable aluminum construction, allowing it to heat up quickly and spread heat evenly throughout the pan. Thanks to the durable hinge that separates the two sections of the pan, it’s easy to heat both surfaces evenly before flipping the contents.

At 9.5 inches across, this is a mid-sized pan that can hold 2-5 eggs. You can also use it to easily make filled omelettes by cracking 2-3 eggs into each side and lightly cooking them, with ham or vegetables on top of the eggs in one side. Close the pan for a large, thick and filling omelette.

If you like to prepare frittatas or like your omelettes with plenty of fillings, you’ll enjoy the Nordic Ware Italian Frittata and Omelette Pan. Priced just under $30, this is a high quality pan with an interesting design that delivers good value for money.

Click here to check the current price for the Nordic Ware Italian Frittata and Omelette Pan on Amazon.

Lodge Pro-Logic P10S3 Pre-Seasoned Skillet

best cast iron omelette skillet

Lodge is famous for making excellent cast iron cookware, and the Pro-Logic P10S3 Skillet is a great example of why. This pre-seasoned cast iron skillet measures 10 inches across and cooks flawless omelettes, frittatas and other egg dishes.

Since this is a cast iron pan, it heats slightly slower than aluminum. However, it retains heat very well and distributes heat evenly throughout the cooking surface, making it perfect for flat dishes that require steady, even heat.

Because this isn’t a non-stick pan, you’ll need to apply oil, butter or another source of fat before you prepare your omelette. If you’re a health conscious chef, you’re ultimately best off buying a non-stick pan, as it’s very difficult to successfully cook eggs in this pan without using oil.

By far the biggest advantage of this pan is the final product it produces. Food cooked in this pan tastes rich and satisfying, with a unique taste that’s difficult to replicate in a non-stick aluminum frying pan.

If you’re a fan of cast iron cooking or a newbie chef interested in preparing your omelettes the old-fashioned way, the Lodge Pro-Logic P10S3 Pre-Seasoned Skillet is a great buy. Just don’t expect to cook your eggs the same way you would in a modern non-stick omelette pan.

Click here to check the current price for the Lodge Pro-Logic P10S3 Pre-Seasoned Skillet on Amazon.

The Best Omelette Pans: Quick Recap

Omelette pans are cheap and compact, making them a great addition to your kitchen. As well as using them to prepare omelettes, you can also use them as a small frying pan for meals, heating liquids and even preparing cuts of chicken, pork, beef and other meats.

Do you have an omelette pan, or do you cook omelettes in your regular frying pan? If you have a favorite pan that you think is perfect for preparing omelettes, let us know the brand and model name in the comments and we’ll add it to our “to review” list for future buyer’s guides.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *